Rich Sutton:当前 LLM 停止学习,真正的智能需要持续从经验中学习Rich Sutton: Why AI Models Stop Learning and How to Restart It
The Takeaway:当前大语言模型在训练后权重冻结,无法真正持续学习;真正的智能必须在“大世界”中从自身经验持续更新,摆脱人类数据和合成数据的瓶颈。
强化学习发明者、Bitter Lesson 作者 Rich Sutton 与前学生 Khurram Javed 共同创办 Oak Lab,目标是实现 Alberta Plan 中的持续深度学习和抽象形成。Sutton 强调:“我并不激进,是整个领域变得奇怪了。在 AI 热潮之前,学习天然就是持续的,根本不需要专门叫‘continual learning’。”
Bitter Lesson 的核心是:不要被人类知识分心,专注能随算力扩展的学习与搜索方法。LLM 既是正面例子(大规模吞下互联网),也是负面例子(互联网有限,世界远比数据大,最终被人类知识卡住)。合成数据同样依赖人类决定“什么是好数据”,无法摆脱瓶颈。真正的路径是让 agent 自己从经验中学习模型、形成抽象并用于规划,同时用 per-weight step-size 优化和 continual backprop 解决灾难性遗忘。
Oak Lab 的愿景是构建能同时处理低层感知运动与高层抽象、自我保持一致性的系统,预计在算力与算法进步下 5-10 年内可实现高效实现。LLM 是语言能力的巨大突破,但只占智能的大约四分之一,远未完成。
强化学习发明者、Bitter Lesson 作者 Rich Sutton 与前学生 Khurram Javed 共同创办 Oak Lab,目标是实现 Alberta Plan 中的持续深度学习和抽象形成。Sutton 强调:“我并不激进,是整个领域变得奇怪了。在 AI 热潮之前,学习天然就是持续的,根本不需要专门叫‘continual learning’。”
Bitter Lesson 的核心是:不要被人类知识分心,专注能随算力扩展的学习与搜索方法。LLM 既是正面例子(大规模吞下互联网),也是负面例子(互联网有限,世界远比数据大,最终被人类知识卡住)。合成数据同样依赖人类决定“什么是好数据”,无法摆脱瓶颈。真正的路径是让 agent 自己从经验中学习模型、形成抽象并用于规划,同时用 per-weight step-size 优化和 continual backprop 解决灾难性遗忘。
Oak Lab 的愿景是构建能同时处理低层感知运动与高层抽象、自我保持一致性的系统,预计在算力与算法进步下 5-10 年内可实现高效实现。LLM 是语言能力的巨大突破,但只占智能的大约四分之一,远未完成。
The Takeaway: Current LLMs freeze their weights after training and stop truly learning; real intelligence requires continual learning from an agent's own experience in a vast world, free from human-curated or synthetic-data bottlenecks.
Reinforcement-learning pioneer and author of “The Bitter Lesson” Rich Sutton, together with former student Khurram Javed, founded Oak Lab to pursue continual deep learning and abstraction formation as outlined in the Alberta Plan. Sutton insists: “I’m not weird. The field is weird. Before the AI craziness you wouldn’t have to say continual learning because it wouldn’t make any sense to talk about learning that wasn’t continual. All learning is continual.”
The Bitter Lesson’s essence is to avoid distraction by human knowledge and focus on methods that scale with computation—search and learning. LLMs are both a positive example (massive scaling on internet data) and a negative one (the internet is finite; the world is vastly larger, so reliance on human knowledge eventually holds progress back). Synthetic data remains bottlenecked by humans who must decide what constitutes good data. The real path is agents that learn models from their own experience, form the right abstractions for planning, and update weights continuously—using techniques such as per-weight step-size optimization and continual backprop to avoid catastrophic forgetting.
Oak Lab’s ambition is a system that spans low-level sensorimotor knowledge to high-level abstractions while remaining self-consistent. With algorithmic and hardware progress they expect this to become practical within 5–10 years. LLMs represent a major breakthrough in fluid language use, yet that is only about a quarter of intelligence; the rest remains unfinished.
查看原文 →
Reinforcement-learning pioneer and author of “The Bitter Lesson” Rich Sutton, together with former student Khurram Javed, founded Oak Lab to pursue continual deep learning and abstraction formation as outlined in the Alberta Plan. Sutton insists: “I’m not weird. The field is weird. Before the AI craziness you wouldn’t have to say continual learning because it wouldn’t make any sense to talk about learning that wasn’t continual. All learning is continual.”
The Bitter Lesson’s essence is to avoid distraction by human knowledge and focus on methods that scale with computation—search and learning. LLMs are both a positive example (massive scaling on internet data) and a negative one (the internet is finite; the world is vastly larger, so reliance on human knowledge eventually holds progress back). Synthetic data remains bottlenecked by humans who must decide what constitutes good data. The real path is agents that learn models from their own experience, form the right abstractions for planning, and update weights continuously—using techniques such as per-weight step-size optimization and continual backprop to avoid catastrophic forgetting.
Oak Lab’s ambition is a system that spans low-level sensorimotor knowledge to high-level abstractions while remaining self-consistent. With algorithmic and hardware progress they expect this to become practical within 5–10 years. LLMs represent a major breakthrough in fluid language use, yet that is only about a quarter of intelligence; the rest remains unfinished.